Part VII of a series.

After a seven-hour flight from Boston, I felt happy to finally stretch my legs once I reached my home in California. Taking over my family’s red plush couch in the living room with the television remote in one hand and my favorite Snuggie-esque orange-and-brown blanket draped over my legs, I turned the channel to VH1. Excited to have arrived at home a few days before the Thanksgiving break officially started and in time for the Kelly Clarkson Live Soundstage episode, I told my mom to join me in the Kelly sing-a-long. We turned on the closed captioning and I commenced singing at the top of my lungs.

            “What doesn’t kill you makes you stronger / Stand a little taller…”

I personally thought she looked gorgeous in her curve-hugging shimmering red dress and proclaimed to my mom how proud I was of the pop rock crooner with the powerful pipes who I’d voted for nine years ago on American Idol.

“She does have a really unique voice,” my mom agreed. “But the media has just been so harsh on her about…you know…”

            “What?” I asked, eyes still glued to the screen.

            “Doesn’t mean I’m lonely when I’m alone…”

            My mom gestured to the TV. “Her weight.”

Sure, Kelly definitely didn’t look as skin-and-bones as her fellow female Idol alumni did. The ones who’d lost loads of pounds upon finding themselves thrust into the limelight: country star Carrie Underwood, Oscar-winner Jennifer Hudson, new NBC primetime darling-to-be Katharine McPhee.

The mention of her weight echoed back words from articles that I’d read in magazines, insulting Kelly for her image; vicious remarks about how she needed to cut down on the catered food that came with her new celebrity status. Outrage that I’d felt then at the critics came roaring back to me as I watched her sing to a packed room of grinning fans.

“What doesn’t kill you makes a fighter / Footsteps even lighter…”

Just because she doesn’t have skeletal arms or razor-sharp cheekbones doesn’t mean that she deserves less respect for her profession as a singer. Perhaps the blow of the critical words on Kelly hit me because I’m also a woman who’s planning to go into the media industry. Whether I work as a broadcaster or actress—or ideally, both—I know that I’m setting myself up for a world of constant scrutiny over my appearance.

The black-and-white words on the screen to Kelly’s song blurred as thoughts of my recent arts-infused undertaking—my thesis—entered my head.

In writing my senior thesis, an autoethnography that reflects on my values and stories from my life so far, and preparing for a performance to accompany the piece, I’ve needed to engage in a lot of self-exploration. One integral part of autoethnography involves digging deep into the mine of memories and uncovering the difficult parts of my life that I haven’t wanted to relive.

With eyes still on Kelly, I saw my own struggle with appearance and skinniness. Some of the moments in my past that still make me shudder today.

The time in fifth grade when my mom’s friend came to visit and in all seriousness called me thunder thighs, asking me if I had cellulite at ten years old. Lunches in seventh grade, when I refused to eat anything around my friends except for a chocolate milk or yogurt every day, only to have them call me out on it and attempt to force-feed me rice. One day in eighth grade science class when my teacher began her lecture on anorexia and a classmate, sitting two seats away from me, coughed my name loudly enough for everyone to hear. High school gym class when I would take extreme care to suck in my stomach if I was changing around others in the locker room. All the way up to college when one of my blockmates told me I would have to lose a lot of weight if I really wanted to make it in the movie business.

Nothing hurts more when someone you consider your close friend jabs at your jugular. He knew how much I wanted to make it as an actress and he also knew how sensitive I’d been about my weight for all my past years.

“Doesn’t mean I’m over cuz you’re gone…”

Why couldn’t I be respected for my craft? For my ability to write, produce, and report on news pieces? Or for my attempts to act out different characters onstage and on-screen? Didn’t the content of the story matter anymore?

More importantly, when did looking like a mannequin become equivalent to “looking great” for women?

This challenge of staying skinny just to appear attractive plagues women to an unhealthy extent. When we lose weight, we’re met with positive feedback and praise. When we gain weight, we encounter subtle and some not-so-subtle pokes at our self-esteem, even from our loved ones. I remember returning home for winter break three years ago only to have family friends tell me they thought I’d gained the famous freshman 15.

It’s actually women like Kelly who we should praise—ones who don’t feel pressured to conform to the opinions of others, ones who don’t let the sticks and stones turn them to skin and bones.

At the time of this writing, I do still allow worries of my weight’s correlation with my future career to occupy my thoughts and feel concerned about calories. However, I realize that at the end of the day, if I’m happy with myself, I shouldn’t let anyone else convince me otherwise. And no woman should either.

“What doesn’t kill you makes you stronger, stronger / Just me, myself, and I.”

Sanyee Yuan ’12 (syuan@fas) thinks we should break away from reducing women to their appearances.

 

Part VI of a series.

This piece might be better suited for the Valentine’s Day issue next spring, but there’s something in the air that makes me think winter is also a good season to talk about love, or to consider writing and performing ethnography on love lives, anyway.

For my senior thesis, I’m writing an autoethnography—assembling together anecdotes from my life up until now and organizing them by the thread of similar thematic elements. Afterward, I plan to create and perform a one-woman show about my work and share these stories with the community on campus.

Since the thesis makes it necessary for me to constantly dive into my pool of memories and pick out the fragments that mean the most to me, I’ve begun honing my powers of observation.  I’ve found myself reflecting over significant moments and milestones through the lens of my younger self, my present self, and the others involved in my experiences over time.

Last night, I went out to dinner and drinks with some good friends at Border Café. As we sipped margaritas from salt-rimmed glasses and munched on warm, crunchy nachos, one of the guys talked about his interaction with a woman at a grocery store. He had taken over for the cashier during the afternoon and since the woman in line was purchasing alcohol, he had to ask for identification. She looked about 45 years old, he told us—but when she flashed her driver’s license, he realized that she was actually well over 60. He couldn’t help but ask her how she managed to look nearly 20 years younger than her age, and instead of displaying obvious offense or self-injury at his bold query, she leaned over conspiratorially and shared her secret.

“As long as you have love in your life, you’ll be forever young.”

Chuckling at this point in the story, he revealed to us in an (admittedly cute) self-deprecating manner that he was single at the moment, and he then went on to recount how he’d told her that he currently had no love in his life.

As he talks, I begin to trace over the love lines in my life. I don’t believe they’ve run too extraordinarily deep—when it comes to boys, guys, men, dudes, etc., I’ve never really experienced anything too profound.

There was a time in third grade when I wrote and distributed handmade Valentine’s to everyone in my class. I’d designed a special one for my crush at the time, writing in my loopy cursive, “Dear Vincent. I like you. A lot. Love, Sanyee.” Within five minutes of passing out my cards, Vincent’s best friend, David, had marched over to my table and waving the flimsy card in hand, asked in a demanding tone, “Do you really like Vincent? Because it says here in the card you gave him that you do.”

Instead of feeling mortified, I felt liberated. My sister calls it “the admitting-fest,” which is the moment in which you reveal to someone that you like him or her. After my admitting-fest for Vincent, I realized that I actually didn’t like him so much anymore. It had just been fun to crush on someone and now the excitement was over.

Following Vincent, there was Ben in middle school. Nothing but constant gossiping, plastic promise rings, and long insubstantial phone conversations were exchanged.

Then there was the First Boyfriend in senior year of high school, who was my host brother during my stay with a host family in California while I was competing in California’s Junior Miss. It was a perfect example of the proximity principle in relationship psychology.

After him, there was the First Dating Experience, consisting of actually going out with a guy who I’d known since middle school but had never gotten to know. My energy and enthusiasm rapidly expended soon after the time spent watching plays and attending dances together. Plus, it was time for college applications.

I moved into the virtual realm of relationships with the Facebook Pen Pal, a guy with whom I shared an epic wall-to-wall but did not meet in person until three months after our continual correspondence. Everyone’s got to have at least one cyber-relationship in his or her lifetime, right?

Two summers ago came the First Real Relationship, combined with the First Long-Distance Experience. Coupled with highs and lows, we started with a storybook romance, living next door to each other on our summer program in Cambridge, UK. Europe became the backdrop for us as we explored the Eiffel Tower together, ate gelato side by side in Italy, and took midnight strolls along the Tower Bridge in London. But, as in true Taylor Swiftian fashion, the lighthearted, sunny summer dissipated as the cold, unforgiving winter descended and our level of compatibility dwindled as we spent more time apart.

“Are you going to finish that?”

One of my friends at the table points at my dark red sangria, with the fine orange wedge glistening at the edge of the glass. I’m jolted back to the present, surrounded by my friends, plates of Tex-Mex cuisine, and strains of inaudible country music.

I smile back at him. “Go for it.”

The friend with the grocery store story asks for a sip too. It becomes a communal drink and I can’t help but marvel at how I haven’t felt this happy and carefree in months. This is the kind of love and companionship I’d prefer any day: having friends to go out with so we can laugh over our adventures and embark on even crazier ones.

Maybe this is the kind of love I should write about for my thesis.

Sanyee Yuan ’12 (syuan@fas) is wondering where her love lines will take her next. 

 

Part V of a series.

The year is 2008. I sit down in front of my computer and attempt to fill out the Harvard Advising Questionnaire before my freshman year. According to Harvard, I need to list my top three extracurricular activities, number my top three possible fields of study, and answer a question about where I want to be in ten years.

The drop-down list of concentrations grabs my attention. During my college applications process, I had listed Communications and Broadcast Journalism as my proposed major, holding tight to my dream of becoming a news reporter. Looking at Harvard’s many options, I browse the web sites of the departments for English, Literature, and Visual & Environmental Studies. An FAQ section on the Harvard academics page about creating one’s own major on campus leads me to click on the Special Concentrations department. The more I probe through the site and read through the creative names and thesis projects of previous concentrations, the more I want to pursue one. I imagine taking classes from the English and VES department to make my own study for Communications.

However, when I arrive on campus during Opening Days in September, I meet with my academic adviser over lunch in Loker Commons and she discourages me from pursuing a Special Concentration. Feeling somewhat defeated, I decide to hide my intentions of pursuing a Special Concentration.

The following spring, I enroll in a freshman seminar called The Art of Storytelling, in which I study various forms of narrative. For my final project, I write a short screenplay about my transition from high school to Harvard. When I go in for a meeting with my seminar professor to talk about the project, we begin to discuss the creative projects that students undertake in her department, Folklore & Mythology—and I leave her office contemplating a concentration in F&M.

By the time sophomore fall begins, I spend my spare hours sifting through the Registrar’s web site. There, I browse classes—searching for ones that focus on storytelling, journalism, media studies, and the arts. I find that I can study the personal narratives of people and their social interactions in Psychology and change my mind from F&M to Psych. However, I am still wavering between Psych, Sociology, VES, and Social Anthropology. Finally, on the night before study cards are due, I write an article for the Indy about how happy I am to be an official Psych concentrator.

However, when I chart out my classes for sophomore spring during winter break, my happiness fades away. I realize that I do not want to spend hours in statistics classes, labs, and MCB 80. It’s just not my passion. I decide to switch to English so I can take creative writing classes and tell my own stories. Before I start applying for a change of concentration, one other ‘department’ on the Registrar’s site catches my eye—the Dramatic Arts secondary field. I meet with my freshman seminar professor, who knows about my love for storytelling and ask her if there is any way for me to pursue Dramatic Arts as a concentration instead of as a secondary field. She tells me that the only way to do that is to apply through a…wait for it…Special Concentration.

Realizing that I’ve come full-circle since my discovery of the Special Concentrations department pre-freshman-year, I decide to go for it. At the end of April, I find an adviser in the English department. Knowing that the SC committee meets twice a year to read over applications, I am intent on making the fall deadline for October of my junior year. When I return to campus after the summer, I take a gamble on choosing my classes—signing up for a schedule composed of five classes for a concentration that has not been officially approved yet. At this point, I am still registered in the Psych department and the Director of Undergraduate Studies glances nervously at me as I ask for her signature and tells me that I am taking a big risk. If my concentration does not get approved, I will need to spend the rest of my three semesters cramming in courses for Psych or whichever department I fall into.

On Yom Kippur that month, I decide to fast in solidarity as I have done the past two years with my blockmate and I stay inside, working all day on honing my proposal for my Special Concentration in Narrative in Film & Performance. I turn it in the next week and hold my breath until I get a response.

It is rejected.

As my eyes look over the email from the committee, I realize the reason for the rejection is not my concentration; it’s my adviser. She is not going to be on campus my senior year. This means that if I can find a new adviser, my concentration can still get approved. My adviser, apologetic that she has not mentioned her forthcoming absence from Harvard, directs me to another professor in the English department who specializes in rhetoric and regularly pushes for public speaking initiatives on campus. I get in touch with him and make one more permutation of my proposal. He agrees to advise me and on October 25, 2010, I receive a letter approving my Special Concentration in Narrative in Rhetoric & Performance.

Through my Special Concentration, I have been able to take some of the coolest classes at Harvard.

I create dances about my life through Introduction to Choreography. I study the formulas of great American speeches with a visiting professor from Northwestern’s Rhetoric department. I cross-register at the Kennedy School and learn how to weave together effective stories in public narrative from a professor who participated in the Cesar Chavez campaign. I delve into the study of the human voice and its variety in Vocal Production for the Stage. I craft my power of persuasion through a course on the Elements of Rhetoric. I design a one-on-one tutorial with a former Good Morning America producer to study talk show hosts and Ryan Seacrest’s on-camera interviewing techniques.

Every class that I’ve taken for my concentration has emphasized the content of presenting myself in public, whether it is through speech or performance. Not only have I had incredible amounts of fun in each class and gotten to know the stories of each of my individual classmates and professors, I have also received an immeasurable preparation for my future career in broadcast journalism and the performing arts.

My concentration will culminate in my senior thesis, an autoethnography about my life, a script for a play based on the autoethnography, and a live one-woman performance of the play.

I cannot describe how thankful I am for the chance to have pursued my real-world passions in the academic realm here. When I wave my diploma in the air this spring, I will be happy knowing that that rectangular piece of paper represents the truly once-in-a-lifetime education that I have received.

Sanyee Yuan’12 (syuan@fas) wants you to create a Special Concentration in Autoethnographic Studies. Or anything else that stimulates your interests.

 

 

 

Calendar

February 2012
S M T W T F S
« Jan    
 1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
26272829  

Comp the Indy!

We meet every Thursday at 8:00 PM in the Boylston Mezzanine (right above Ticknor Lounge). Come visit! We don't bite! If you want to find out more, contact us and indicate you're a comper – we'll send you information ASAP!

© and ® The Harvard Independent, Inc., 1969-2012.