After a seven-hour flight from Boston, I felt happy to finally stretch my legs once I reached my home in California. Taking over my family’s red plush couch in the living room with the television remote in one hand and my favorite Snuggie-esque orange-and-brown blanket draped over my legs, I turned the channel to VH1. Excited to have arrived at home a few days before the Thanksgiving break officially started and in time for the Kelly Clarkson Live Soundstage episode, I told my mom to join me in the Kelly sing-a-long. We turned on the closed captioning and I commenced singing at the top of my lungs.
“What doesn’t kill you makes you stronger / Stand a little taller…”
I personally thought she looked gorgeous in her curve-hugging shimmering red dress and proclaimed to my mom how proud I was of the pop rock crooner with the powerful pipes who I’d voted for nine years ago on American Idol.
“She does have a really unique voice,” my mom agreed. “But the media has just been so harsh on her about…you know…”
“What?” I asked, eyes still glued to the screen.
“Doesn’t mean I’m lonely when I’m alone…”
My mom gestured to the TV. “Her weight.”
Sure, Kelly definitely didn’t look as skin-and-bones as her fellow female Idol alumni did. The ones who’d lost loads of pounds upon finding themselves thrust into the limelight: country star Carrie Underwood, Oscar-winner Jennifer Hudson, new NBC primetime darling-to-be Katharine McPhee.
The mention of her weight echoed back words from articles that I’d read in magazines, insulting Kelly for her image; vicious remarks about how she needed to cut down on the catered food that came with her new celebrity status. Outrage that I’d felt then at the critics came roaring back to me as I watched her sing to a packed room of grinning fans.
“What doesn’t kill you makes a fighter / Footsteps even lighter…”
Just because she doesn’t have skeletal arms or razor-sharp cheekbones doesn’t mean that she deserves less respect for her profession as a singer. Perhaps the blow of the critical words on Kelly hit me because I’m also a woman who’s planning to go into the media industry. Whether I work as a broadcaster or actress—or ideally, both—I know that I’m setting myself up for a world of constant scrutiny over my appearance.
The black-and-white words on the screen to Kelly’s song blurred as thoughts of my recent arts-infused undertaking—my thesis—entered my head.
In writing my senior thesis, an autoethnography that reflects on my values and stories from my life so far, and preparing for a performance to accompany the piece, I’ve needed to engage in a lot of self-exploration. One integral part of autoethnography involves digging deep into the mine of memories and uncovering the difficult parts of my life that I haven’t wanted to relive.
With eyes still on Kelly, I saw my own struggle with appearance and skinniness. Some of the moments in my past that still make me shudder today.
The time in fifth grade when my mom’s friend came to visit and in all seriousness called me thunder thighs, asking me if I had cellulite at ten years old. Lunches in seventh grade, when I refused to eat anything around my friends except for a chocolate milk or yogurt every day, only to have them call me out on it and attempt to force-feed me rice. One day in eighth grade science class when my teacher began her lecture on anorexia and a classmate, sitting two seats away from me, coughed my name loudly enough for everyone to hear. High school gym class when I would take extreme care to suck in my stomach if I was changing around others in the locker room. All the way up to college when one of my blockmates told me I would have to lose a lot of weight if I really wanted to make it in the movie business.
Nothing hurts more when someone you consider your close friend jabs at your jugular. He knew how much I wanted to make it as an actress and he also knew how sensitive I’d been about my weight for all my past years.
“Doesn’t mean I’m over cuz you’re gone…”
Why couldn’t I be respected for my craft? For my ability to write, produce, and report on news pieces? Or for my attempts to act out different characters onstage and on-screen? Didn’t the content of the story matter anymore?
More importantly, when did looking like a mannequin become equivalent to “looking great” for women?
This challenge of staying skinny just to appear attractive plagues women to an unhealthy extent. When we lose weight, we’re met with positive feedback and praise. When we gain weight, we encounter subtle and some not-so-subtle pokes at our self-esteem, even from our loved ones. I remember returning home for winter break three years ago only to have family friends tell me they thought I’d gained the famous freshman 15.
It’s actually women like Kelly who we should praise—ones who don’t feel pressured to conform to the opinions of others, ones who don’t let the sticks and stones turn them to skin and bones.
At the time of this writing, I do still allow worries of my weight’s correlation with my future career to occupy my thoughts and feel concerned about calories. However, I realize that at the end of the day, if I’m happy with myself, I shouldn’t let anyone else convince me otherwise. And no woman should either.
“What doesn’t kill you makes you stronger, stronger / Just me, myself, and I.”
Sanyee Yuan ’12 (syuan@fas) thinks we should break away from reducing women to their appearances.



